1869 9 Over 9 Indian Head Penny Value: What Is It Worth in 2026?

⚠ Key date / rare varietyMintage: not recorded
Estimated value · Source: USACoinBook price guide (updated Feb 2026)
1869 Indian Head Penny · 9 Over 9
Mint: Philadelphia (no mint mark)
Get it graded

Getting this graded by PCGS or NGC before selling usually pays off. Authentication matters: the 1877, 1909-S, and 1864-L are among the most faked cents in the hobby.

Value by condition

Good (G-4, heavily worn)$175
Very Good (VG-8)$281
Fine (F-12)$584
Very Fine (VF-20)$755
Extremely Fine (XF-40)$1,064
About Uncirculated (AU-50)$1,344
Mint State (MS-63, uncirculated)$2,033

Repunched date: the 9 was punched twice, and the earlier digit shows clearly under magnification. One of the classic date varieties of the series.

What an 1869 Indian Head penny looks like

Indian Head cent obverse and reverse: Liberty in a feathered headdress with date below; ONE CENT inside an oak wreath with a shield on top on the back
Reference photo (a 1909 coin — this oak-wreath-and-shield reverse was used from 1860 to 1909; the 1859 first year shows a plainer laurel wreath). The date is on the front, below the portrait. Only the 1908-S and 1909-S carry a mint mark — a small S under the wreath on the back; every other year was struck in Philadelphia with no letter. Photo: Brandon Grossardt, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The base design is the same as the photo — the 9 Over 9 variety is described in the sections below.

How to confirm it's genuine

  • The date is on the obverse below the portrait. Only 1908-S and 1909-S carry a mint mark (under the wreath on the reverse) — every other year is Philadelphia with no mark.
  • Overdates need a magnifier: look for traces of the underlying digit inside or beside the final one.
  • Never clean the coin: cleaning destroys the original surface and can cut the value in half.
  • For any coin worth more than $200, PCGS/NGC grading fees (~$20–50) are money well spent.

Where to sell this coin

  • eBay works best in the $1.00–$200 range. Take clear photos of both sides in natural light, and put the year, variety, and approximate grade in the title.
  • A local coin dealer is the fastest way to cash out, but expect 60–70% of guide prices. Common-date Indian Head pennies sell well by the roll or in mixed lots.
  • Graded high-value coins do best at auction houses like Heritage Auctions or Stack's Bowers, where realized prices are public.

Related coins